when a Google AI Overview appears, the top-ranking page now gets about 58% fewer clicks.

less than a year ago that figure was 34.5%.

SEO (search engine optimisation, basically getting found on Google) was built on one deal: you rank, people click. AI search is quietly breaking that deal, and marketing teams are scrambling to work out what replaces it.

How AI search is changing the way people find brands

the clearest data first. Ahrefs compared 300,000 keywords between December 2023 and December 2025:

→ for keywords with an AI Overview, the top result's click-through rate (the share of searchers who click) fell from 7.3% to 1.6% → that's about 58% below where it should have been without AI Overviews → Ahrefs' April 2025 study had the drop at 34.5%, so it's getting worse, not better

Pew Research backs this up with real browsing data from 900 US adults (Pew):

  1. people clicked a normal result on 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, against 15% without one
  2. they clicked a link inside the AI summary on just 1% of visits
  3. 26% ended their browsing session right there, against 16% without a summary

and yet Google is doing fine. at its Q4 results in February, Google reported more Search usage than ever and 17% Search revenue growth. queries in AI Mode, its chatbot-style search, are about three times longer than traditional searches.

so people are searching MORE. they're just clicking less.

then there's ChatGPT. with around 800 million weekly users, OpenAI started testing ads in February for free and Go users in the US:

→ ads sit below the answer, labelled as sponsored → OpenAI says they don't change what ChatGPT recommends → no ads in health, mental health or politics conversations

answer engines (tools that give you an answer instead of a list of links) are becoming an ad channel in their own right.

What uni won't teach you about AI search and SEO

marketing modules often still teach SEO as keywords, backlinks and ranking reports. what's shifting:

  1. ranking first isn't the win it was. if the answer sits above you, position one can still mean very few clicks
  2. traffic is a weaker metric. being mentioned inside AI answers matters, and most dashboards don't track it yet
  3. questions are getting longer. three times longer queries mean people describe their actual problem, not two keywords
  4. AI can get your brand wrong. the same hallucination problem courts are sanctioning lawyers for can misdescribe your product to a customer

The critical-thinking move: 5 questions for any AI search strategy

  1. does the AI answer this query completely? quick facts and definitions often end on the results page. comparisons, opinions and fresh or local needs still earn clicks
  2. what does the AI say about us right now? ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode about the brand and its competitors. write down what's wrong or missing
  3. where does the AI get its information? look at the sources it cites. those pages are the new battleground
  4. what metric replaces clicks? branded searches, direct visits, sign ups. pick something that still moves when clicks fall
  5. who's selling the certainty? "AI SEO" services promise a lot. like the AI investing hype, ask for the benchmark before you believe the result

What to do this month

  1. run a brand audit in three AI tools. pick a brand you like, ask the same five questions in each, and note every mismatch and missing source
  2. read the Ahrefs study and turn the position-by-position numbers into one slide you could present
  3. rewrite one piece of content for answers: question-style headings, a direct answer in the first lines, real data with sources
  4. follow the ChatGPT ads test. sketch how you'd measure an ad that appears under an answer rather than on a results page

we'll keep tracking this on our marketing hub.

so TLDR: AI search means more searching and fewer clicks, so marketers now need to win the answer, not just the ranking.

what's the last thing you searched where the AI answer meant you never clicked a single link?

Sources

Get the next issue by email

theVANTAGEd is written by students to bring critical thinking to AI across real industries. One issue every two weeks.