97% of marketing leaders now use AI in their daily creative work. 78% of consumers would rather see ads made by people.

That gap is the whole story of AI content in marketing right now. Brands can make ten times more content for the same budget. Customers are getting better at ignoring it (and a growing chunk actively hold it against you).

The consensus: more AI content means more reach

The pitch goes:

→ AI makes content almost free → more posts, more pages, more ads means more chances to be seen → so whoever produces the most wins

And marketers are all in. Canva's State of Marketing and AI Report 2026, released in May, surveyed 1,415 marketing leaders and 3,547 consumers across seven countries:

→ 97% of marketing leaders use AI daily in creative work → 99% plan to increase AI investment this year

Why mass-produced AI content backfires

Now look at the other side of the same reports.

1. Consumers notice, and they don't love it. From the same Canva report:

→ 78% would rather see ads made by people, even if AI could make better ones → 70% say AI-generated ads feel like they're missing something → mentions of "AI slop" in media monitoring rose ninefold → 41% of marketing leaders say slop is already a considerable challenge

2. Trust is dropping fast. Fractl's Q2 2026 survey of 1,008 US consumers found the share saying heavy AI use would reduce their trust in a brand rose from 20% in 2025 to 39% in 2026 (Digital Applied). Nearly doubled in a year.

3. It hurts on social, where volume is easiest. Research from the Retail Technology Show, reported by CMOtech, surveyed 1,000+ shoppers:

→ 53% distrust AI-generated social content (58% of Gen Z) → 48% say human-led content is more likely to make them buy (70% of Gen Z) → separate Klaviyo data in the same piece: 50% noticed low-quality AI material from brands in the past six months

4. Search punishes it. Google's spam policy calls it scaled content abuse when "many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating Search rankings and not helping users".

And the May 2026 core update (21 May to 2 June) showed it again. SEO analyst Glenn Gabe described a site that scaled lower-quality content, AI-translated it into several languages and got hit hard. He calls the pattern "Mt. AI": sites that scale AI content surge, then crash.

So the "volume wins" maths breaks in three places at once: people, platforms and search.

Where the consensus is right: AI in marketing still pays

Not everything here is anti-AI. Canva found 68% of marketing leaders say AI has increased marketing-influenced business decisions.

The difference is what the AI is FOR:

bad: 200 near-identical blog posts a month to "win SEO" good: one properly researched piece, with AI helping on research, variations, testing and translation you actually check

AI as a production line makes you look like everyone else. AI as an assistant to a real point of view makes you faster at being different.

We saw the same thing in journalism in AI slop and trusted media: when content gets cheap, trust becomes the scarce thing.

What uni won't teach you about AI content

Marketing degrees teach the funnel, segmentation and the 4Ps. Where they lag:

  1. output is still treated as the KPI. Posts per week, pages published. Those numbers are now almost free to inflate
  2. search is taught as keywords. How AI search is changing SEO gets a lecture, if you're lucky
  3. rights get skipped. Who owns AI-made assets is still being fought out, as we covered in AI and copyright in the creative industries

The critical-thinking move: 4 questions before you scale AI content

  1. Would anyone miss this if we didn't publish it? If not, more of it won't help
  2. What does this say that only we could say? Data, experience, a view. If the answer is nothing, AI just made a commodity cheaper
  3. Would we be happy to label it as AI-assisted? If the plan only works when people can't tell, it's a bad plan
  4. What's the trust metric, not just the reach metric? Track replies, saves, return visitors and conversions, not impressions

What to do this month

  1. Audit one brand you like. Scroll its last 30 social posts and mark which feel templated. Compare engagement on those vs the rest
  2. Run a small test on your own channel or a society account: one AI-mass post vs one carefully made post on the same topic. Compare saves and replies
  3. Write one piece AI couldn't: built on your own data, interview notes or an event you actually attended. Use AI to edit it, not write it
  4. Read the Canva and Fractl numbers and bring one to your next interview. It shows you think about trust, not just output

More on AI across the industry is on our marketing hub.

so TLDR: AI makes content nearly free, which is exactly why mass-produced content stops working. Use AI to make fewer, sharper, more human things, not more of the same.

What's one brand whose content you'd notice was AI-generated straight away, and what gave it away?

Sources

Get the next issue by email

theVANTAGEd is written by students to bring critical thinking to AI across real industries. One issue every two weeks.